Ten Minutes of AI Help Can Weaken Your Persistence, New Study Finds
A peer-reviewed study presented this week at the Conference on Language Modeling suggests that relying on an AI assistant for just ten minutes can make people less willing to keep going when a task gets hard. The effect showed up as soon as the assistant was taken away.
What the researchers did
The team ran three randomized controlled trials with 1,222 participants recruited online. In the first experiment, 354 people were asked to solve 15 basic fraction problems. One group worked unaided; the other had ChatGPT open alongside and could even ask it for the answer. After 12 problems, the AI was removed. A second experiment with 667 participants repeated the design, and a third, with 201 participants, used an SAT reading comprehension task.
What they found
The group with AI access started out more accurate. Once the tool was taken away, their accuracy and persistence dropped sharply: they were more likely to get answers wrong or skip questions, while the group that never had AI stuck with the task and finished more successfully. The same pattern appeared across all three experiments.
Why the authors think it happens
The researchers point to the loss of what they call "productive struggle". When AI produces answers in seconds, people get used to that speed, and anything that takes longer starts to feel inefficient. Co-author Brian Christian, a research fellow at UC Berkeley's Center for Human-Compatible AI, said: "We showed, ironically, that they are often helping us in ways that are kind of unhelpful."
What this could mean for your business
This section is LIID Digital's own reading, not a finding of the study. If your team uses AI to produce first drafts, answers or analysis, it is worth deciding deliberately where the tool should explain and teach, rather than simply hand over a finished result. Christian suggests AI could default to being more instructive, like a tutor, so that human ability is augmented rather than supplanted.
Source: UC Berkeley Research, "Using AI for Just 10 Minutes Erodes Your Ability to Persist at Hard Things", covering the paper "AI Assistance Reduces Persistence and Hurts Independent Performance". The study team included scholars from Carnegie Mellon University, MIT, the University of Oxford and UCLA.
Want AI working for your business? Contact LIID Digital today for advice, a custom build, or a free demo.